Arthur Morgan
Click any of these to view the different scenarios! They're grouped for ease of access :)
The extra stuff
Anything that didn't classify under the other stuff
Arthur has to collect from User's father
Request - low honor!Arthur and User try to invade a home together
Request - Arthur confides in User about his meeting with Sonny (SA MENTION WARNING)
Request - low honor!Arthur breaks into User's house and threatens them
Request - User replaces Eliza; or, User gets pregnant and Arthur decides to sort of step up
Request - Slasher!User hunts down Arthur
Request - Arthur and User were friends before the VDL gang and got separated. But they found each other again
Request - Arthur doesn't want to deal with the child he and User had out of fear of more loss
Request - O'Driscoll and fem!user is captured by Arthur
Established relationship
Scenarios where User and Arthur are already together
Request - young Arthur and User. After he had to break it off with Mary, he dates User. But their argument gets pretty bad
Request - young Arthur and User are in love despite his gang and her family hating each other
Request - Arthur gets to hold his and User's baby for the first time
Request - User is Arthur's controversially young (but still legal) partner
Request - User is Arthur's older partner
Request - Arthur sneaks around with User because her dad doesn't approve (corruption kink)
Request - Just fluff of Arthur and User being married
Request - Arthur and User get into a fight and it could end their relationship
Request - Arthur usually takes break from User, but she's sick this time and might lose their baby (she's pregnant lol)
Fluff and Comfort
Sweet scenarios meant to give comfort and make you happy!
User and Arthur are married, their peaceful morning is interrupted by their children
Request - Arthur is too insecure and oblivious to see User has a fat crush on him
Request - Arthur's partner brings him to town to pamper him
Arthur realizes User hadn't been eating much if at all (POSSIBLE ED)
Request - Arthur loves User, and he accidentally confesses one night
NSFW
Spicy scenarios
Arthur finally finds the time to get User alone
Request - Arthur hires User at a saloon
Request - During some passion, Arthur's breeding kink comes out by accident. Except he and User are both men
Request - Arthur comes back to camp drunk and keeps flirting with User
Request - During intimacy, Arthur feels insecure
Request - low honor!Arthur and low honor!User hate fuck
Request - Arthur gets baby fever (relationship + breeding)
Request - After saving User's family, Arthur expects payment
Request - Arthur is trying to relax after a hard day and User walks in on him
Request - Arthur needs to get off, but his partner is sleeping (somnophilia + relationship)
Request - User wears Arthur's hat while riding him
Request - low honor!Arthur and low honor!User are buddies on a scouting mission. But Arthur has other plans
Request - Arthur ends up liking having a kid and wants another (breeding)
Request - basically "Do Me Instead" but User is high honor
Request - Arthur kind of likes that User cries during sex (dacryphilia)
Request - Arthur fucks the insecurities out of User (relationship)
SFW
Platonic scenarios
Request - Arthur cuddles with User and feeds them fruit
Request - Arthur lets User practice her makeup skills on him. They're like siblings
Request - Arthur teaches User how to break in a horse
Request - User tells Arthur about her abusive brother (TW: INCEST AND ABUSE, PAST TENSE)
User and Arthur are married, bringing their kids Trick-Or-Treating!
AU
Alternate Universes, mostly modern or Omegaverse
Request - Arthur is User's dad's friend - User is in college
Request - User tries to seduce their way out of a speeding ticket
Request - Arthur is User's history professor and he REALLY wants to give them 'extra credit'
Request - omega!User is infatuated with Alpha!Arthur
Request - Arthur is stressed from work and just wants to be dommed
Request - Modern - Stripper!Arthur pretty much
Request - Detective!Arthur has a crush on receptionist!User
Request - Cop!Arthur and cop!User get a night shift together. And it's boring
Request - Arthur has been transformed into a beast and User is his only hope of turning back human
Arthur gave in to instinct and mated with User, and um...He got pregnant...